Flight compensation payout: EU261 model vs €600 cap — accept or verify

Premium Deals
Mighty Travels Premium
Travel in style,
save up to 90%

On flights and hotels worldwide by booking the best deals when they appear.

See Deals

Sponsored

TakeawayDetail
Do not accept a flat €600 cap by defaultEU261 entitlements range from €250 to €600 per passenger
Compute the statutory payout yourself before acceptingUse distance band × number of passengers
Verify the arrival delay independentlyThe offer should be compared with your own EU261 entitlement calculation
Compare cash-equivalent value, not face valueVoucher terms and claim-firm fees routinely erode cash-equivalent value
Accept only if the offer meets your verified figureThe reader rule is to accept only if the offer matches or exceeds the independently computed entitlement

A flat 600 cap offer should be accepted only after you verify your EU261 entitlement yourself.

The answer changes when the distance band, arrival delay, passenger count, voucher terms, or claim-firm fees reduce the offer’s cash-equivalent value below the statutory figure.

Rain slicked airport terminal corridor dusk cool blue light
Rain slicked airport terminal corridor dusk cool blue light

How EU261 actually sets your payout

Under Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 Article 7, the compensation figure is not a flat settlement you negotiate from memory. It is set by two mechanical facts: the great-circle distance of your flight and how late you reached your final destination. The statute places routes into three bands: up to 1,500 km qualifies for 250; 1,500–3,500 km intra-EU qualifies for 400; and over 3,500 km qualifies for 400 or 600 depending on the length of the arrival delay. That band structure is the entire starting point for any EU261 calculation.

To pin down the distance, look up the great-circle distance between your origin and destination using GCMap or the route data published by the airline itself. Use the booked endpoints of the flight, not the total miles you traveled across a connection, and keep the unit consistent: kilometers, because the thresholds are written in kilometers. If the route sits near a boundary, the classification matters more than the precise number, since crossing the 1,500 km line moves the per-passenger figure from 250 to 400.

The delay test is arrival-based, not departure-based. Under the Sturgeon case law (Case C-402/05), eligibility turns on reaching the final destination more than three hours late. A departure that leaves 2h50m behind schedule and recovers part of that time in the air does not meet the trigger; a departure that leaves on time and lands more than three hours late does. Read the arrival time at the final destination on your booking and compare it with the actual arrival time, rather than relying on the gate delay shown at the start of the trip.

Once the band and the arrival delay are fixed, multiply the applicable per-passenger figure by the number of travelers on the booking. That product is your statutory entitlement before any offer is assessed. The over-3,500 km band is the one that splits: the shorter qualifying arrival delay maps to 400 per passenger, while the longer qualifying arrival delay maps to 600 per passenger. The three-hour arrival trigger opens the door; the delay length within that long-haul band selects the higher or lower figure.

This is why a flat 600 offer cannot be judged on the number alone. If your route falls in the shortest band, the statute points to 250 per passenger; if it falls in the middle band, it points to 400; if it falls in the longest band, the arrival delay decides between 400 and 600. Do the band-and-delay arithmetic first, then read the offer against the result. The mechanism in Article 7, applied with the Sturgeon arrival test, gives you a defensible figure before any airline proposal, voucher language, or third-party claim arrangement enters the picture.

Sunlit Mediterranean departure gate with white stone arches
Sunlit Mediterranean departure gate with white stone arches

Verify before you accept: 3 checks

Treat any flat payout as unverified until you have checked the three records that create it: the great-circle distance between the airports, the actual arrival time at the final destination gate, and the passenger count on the booking. Save each record before you reply, because an offer can be revised once you ask questions.

CheckRecord to verifyWhere to get it
DistanceGreat-circle kilometers between the two airportsIndependent mapper screenshot
ArrivalGate-arrival timestamp at final destinationAirline post-flight email or archived tracker
HeadcountPassengers named on the bookingPNR or booking confirmation

For distance, enter the departure and arrival airports into a great-circle mapper and screenshot the kilometer figure with the date and route visible. If the result sits within about 50 km of a band boundary, repeat the search using the exact airport codes and the routing actually flown, then compare the two results before signing. A small difference in measured distance can place the same flight in a different compensation band, so the screenshot is your evidence if the airline's figure differs.

For arrival, use the timestamp in the airline's post-flight email or an archived flight-tracker record, not a memory of the delay. The relevant moment is arrival at the gate at your final destination; wheels-down time can be earlier and is not the same event. If the two timestamps differ, note both and ask which one the offer used.

For headcount, open the PNR or booking confirmation and count every passenger named on it, then divide any single flat offer by that number before comparing it with a per-passenger entitlement. If the offer names only one passenger, or uses a voucher value that cannot be split, request a passenger-by-passenger breakdown in writing. Keep the booking reference and names with your other screenshots.

If any of the three records disagrees with the offer, respond in writing and ask for a corrected amount or a written explanation of the figure used. Do not accept, sign, or assign the claim until the distance, arrival time, and passenger count all match your records. A short delay to verify is cheaper than discovering after acceptance that the payout was based on the wrong band, time, or headcount.

Cash vs voucher vs claim firm compared

Direct cash from the airline is the winner whenever your own verification confirms the full statutory amount and the carrier pays without escalation: it delivers 100% of the entitlement, with no fee, no expiry, and no redemption conditions. Treat that net figure as the benchmark for every other offer.

Airline vouchers are often pitched above the cash figure, such as a larger voucher against a 600 cash amount, but the headline value is not the cash-equivalent value. Before comparing, convert the voucher to realistic cash by checking its expiry date, blackout periods, whether redemption is one-way or round-trip, transferability, and whether it covers taxes and fees. A voucher you cannot use on the itinerary you actually need may be worth less than the cash it replaces.

The claim-firm route can reduce effort, but it also reduces recovery: firms typically take a contingency cut of 25–50% of the amount recovered, and costs may apply on top. Use this route mainly when the airline will not pay, the claim needs enforcement, or you cannot manage the process yourself, and compare the net amount after fees with your verified entitlement.

Route What you actually get Main erosion risk When it wins
Direct cash 100% of the verified statutory entitlement None, if paid as agreed Full amount verified and no escalation needed
Airline voucher Nominal value, often above the cash figure Expiry, blackouts, one-way vs. round-trip redemption, fare restrictions Realistic cash-equivalent meets or beats the entitlement and you will use it
Claim-firm assignment Entitlement minus the contingency fee 25–50% cut plus possible costs Airline non-payment or you need enforcement support

Apply one rule to all three routes: convert each offer to cash-equivalent value, then accept only if that value meets or beats the entitlement you verified yourself. Keep the airline’s written terms, your redemption plan, and any fee agreement with the claim firm so the comparison is documented.

The numbers that decide accept or reject

The decision turns on arithmetic you can do before you reply to the airline. Start with the boundary, because that is where a flat offer does the most damage. A 250 short-haul figure accepted on a flight that is actually 1,600 km forfeits 150 per passenger at the 1,500 km line. On a four-passenger booking, that single unchecked distance costs 600 — the entire value of a short-haul claim, gone. The boundary is not a rounding detail; it is the difference between one tier and the next, multiplied by every seat on the reservation.

Run the same multiplication on any intermediary's cut before you sign an assignment. A claim firm charging 35% on a verified 400 entitlement nets you 260: 400 × 0.35 = 140, and 400 − 140 = 260. If the airline would have paid the 400 directly after one escalation letter, the firm cost you 140 for work you could have done yourself. That 140 is the accept threshold in disguise — any offer whose cash-equivalent value lands below your verified figure by more than the fee you are avoiding should be rejected on math, not on politeness.

Voucher offers need the same conversion before comparison. A voucher is not cash at par unless you can use every euro of it on a purchase you were already going to make; if you would otherwise pay out of pocket for the same ticket, the offset is real, and if you would not, the face value overstates what you received. Apply the fee test first, then the usability test: a voucher that cannot be spent at face value on a planned purchase is worth less than the same number in cash, and a claim-firm payout is worth the verified entitlement minus its percentage. For a verified full-entitlement case where the airline pays directly, direct cash is the winner on both counts — no percentage removed, no spending constraint added.

Keep the comparison in one table so the boundary error and the fee error cannot hide each other:

ScenarioVerified figureWhat you actually receiveGap
€250 offer, flight actually 1,600 km, 4 passengers€400 × 4 = €1,600€250 × 4 = €1,000€600 lost at the boundary
Claim firm, 35% on one passenger€400€260€140 in fees
Direct payment after escalation, one passenger€400€400€0

The rule that follows is narrow and mechanical: compute distance band × passenger count yourself, convert any non-cash offer to what you can actually spend, subtract any fee you would pay, and accept only when the result meets or beats your own number. The 600 cap is a ceiling in the regulation, not a starting bid, and the boundary arithmetic above is the reason a capped-sounding offer can still be short by the whole claim.

What the evidence does not settle

The distance band is a pricing rule, not an eligibility rule. It sets the amount only after you confirm that the journey is covered, the arrival delay reaches the trigger, and no exclusion applies. A flat 600 offer can therefore be wrong in either direction: it may overstate a case that never clears the threshold, or understate one where the full band still applies.

Rerouting changes the arrival test, not the distance test. If the airline puts you on another itinerary and you reach your final destination less than three hours late, no compensation is due even if the original flight was long-haul. The band calculation becomes relevant only after the three-hour arrival trigger is confirmed; until then, distance does not rescue the claim. A downgrade is a separate remedy and should not be folded into delay-style band math.

Connections are measured as one journey only when the whole trip is on one reservation. On a single PNR, the relevant distance runs from the first departure to the final destination, and the delay is measured at that final arrival. Separate tickets break that chain: a missed connection on a self-booked second ticket is not automatically folded into the first flight's distance band, so check whether your PNR actually covers the entire itinerary before applying any band math.

Extraordinary circumstances can remove compensation even when the delay is three hours or more. The distance band sets the amount only if liability exists; if the cause is an extraordinary circumstance that could not have been avoided with reasonable measures, the band may never be reached. Treat the cause as a separate gate from the distance and arrival-time facts.

Where the gates are cleared, the band still holds: one booking, final arrival at least three hours late, and no qualifying exclusion means the statutory distance band governs the per-passenger amount. In those cases, a flat cap should be compared against the verified band rather than accepted as a default.

Run the arithmetic twice before you sign anything. In the worked case the shortfall is 1,000 on a 1,600 entitlement; if your own worksheet produces a positive shortfall, the offer fails the acceptance rule and you respond with the computed figure. If the trigger line reads No, the entitlement row is 0 regardless of distance, and a demand for the band figure is unsupported.

Keep the completed worksheet with the three saved records even after payment lands. A settlement email that omits the per-passenger basis is not a receipt for the full entitlement, and the worksheet is what lets you show, line by line, which figure was verified and which one the airline substituted.

What to do next

StepActionWhy it matters
1Open the official airline site and verify the arrival delay for your flight against the 3 hours threshold used in the EU261 test.The flat €600 cap offer only makes sense if the verified arrival delay actually triggers the entitlement you are comparing.
2Compute your statutory payout yourself using the distance band × number of passengers method, with EU261 entitlements ranging from €250 to €600 per passenger.This gives you the independent figure the offer must match or exceed before you accept.
3Convert any voucher offer to cash-equivalent value by applying its restrictions, including any 35%, 37.5%, or 50% reduction that appears in the offer terms.Voucher face value is not the same as cash-equivalent value, and restrictions can push the offer below your verified figure.
4Subtract any claim-firm fee from the offer's cash-equivalent value before comparing it with your own EU261 entitlement calculation.Claim-firm fees routinely erode what you actually receive, so the comparison must use the net amount.
5Compare the adjusted offer with your verified figure and accept only if it is at least 100% of that figure in cash, or at least equal after voucher restrictions are converted.This is the decision rule: a flat €600 cap should be accepted only after you verify your EU261 entitlement yourself.
6If the distance band, arrival delay, passenger count, voucher terms, or claim-firm fee changes, repeat the calculation before responding to the airline.The answer changes with each of those inputs, so a prior acceptance decision may no longer be valid.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I accept an airline's flat 600 cap offer right away?

Do not accept a flat 600 cap by default; a flat 600 cap offer should be accepted only after you verify your EU261 entitlement yourself.

What range can EU261 entitlements fall within per passenger?

EU261 entitlements range from 250 to 600 per passenger.

How should I compute my statutory payout before responding to the airline?

Compute the statutory payout yourself before accepting by using distance band × number of passengers.

What should I check about the delay before comparing the airline's offer?

Verify the arrival delay independently, because the answer changes when the arrival delay reduces the offer’s cash-equivalent value below the statutory figure.

Why might a voucher offer worth 600 still be worse than cash compensation?

Compare cash-equivalent value, not face value, because voucher terms and claim-firm fees routinely erode cash-equivalent value.

When is the reader rule satisfied for accepting an offer?

Accept only if the offer matches or exceeds the independently computed entitlement.

Quick answers

Should a flat €600 cap offer be accepted by default?Do not accept a flat €600 cap by default.
What range do EU261 entitlements cover per passenger?EU261 entitlements range from €250 to €600 per passenger.
What should you do before accepting an offer?Compute the statutory payout yourself before accepting.
How should the statutory payout be computed?Use distance band × number of passengers.
When should a flat €600 cap offer be accepted?A flat €600 cap offer should be accepted only after you verify your EU261 entitlement yourself.

Also worth reading: How Google Translate helps travelers claim compensation from international airlines: How Google Translate helps travelers · Stop leaving flight compensation money on the table: Stop leaving flight compensation money · Get the full compensation you deserve when airlines cancel your trip: Get the full compensation you

Premium Deals
Mighty Travels Premium
Travel in style,
save up to 90%

On flights and hotels worldwide by booking the best deals when they appear.

See Deals

Sponsored

Research Methodology & Editorial Standards

We begin by defining the specific objectives the reader needs to accomplish. Primary product documentation and authoritative secondary sources are assembled into a verified research corpus; drafting occurs only after this foundation is in place.

Every quantitative claim is subjected to dual-source verification. Any figure that cannot be independently corroborated is either qualified or omitted.

Published · Last reviewed · Owned by the Aiflightrefunds editorial desk (About, Contact, Privacy).

Related answers